Post-Trade Processing Modernization – Fast tracking the benefits of Analytics & AI while driving huge operational efficiencies Is there a financial services organization in the world who...
In November 2013, EMC sued Pure in federal court in Delaware, claiming that Pure infringed five patents involving various data storage technologies. Last week, the case went to trial – and the case wrapped up this afternoon.
Before the trial started, EMC dropped one patent from the case, and the judge in a pre-trial summary judgment ruling found that we didn’t infringe another. In the same ruling, the judge hearing the case found that Pure infringed certain claims of one of EMC’s patents related to de-duplication technology.
The seven-day trial, therefore, focused on two questions:
The jury’s verdict was split.
The jury awarded EMC damages of $14 million. EMC had originally sought more than $80 million.
Our view has been and remains that EMC’s litigious approach to competition primarily reflects efforts to stabilize its storage business as customers around the world abandon the kind of disk-based storage systems EMC pioneered in favor of flash-based storage from innovative companies like Pure. As the trial proceedings made clear, EMC built its own flash-based storage products via acquisition, rather than organic innovation.
We are gratified that the jury agreed with our view of the facts on most of the issues at trial, although we are disappointed with the one ruling not in our favor on one of EMC’s de-duplication patents. We continue to believe that both the facts and the law are on our side on that issue – and we are considering our options for appealing that aspect of the decision.
It is important to note this ruling will not disrupt Pure, our customers or our partners:
As Pure CEO Scott Dietzen wrote in a blog post in 2013, Pure welcomes marketplace competition. Competition drives innovation and customer value. Competition makes our products better and makes us into a better company, more attuned to customer and partner needs. Competition also fuels market growth. We look forward to continuing to compete with EMC in the public marketplace.